Literary Conversations provides a space for young minds to wend their way through literature, speaking their minds and making meaning with others through meaningful dialogue.
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
Ella Enchanted Conversations
24 comments:
Anonymous
said...
So far Ella Enchanted is about a girl who is cursed by a fairy who thinks she's giving gifts when she’s really laying a curse of the person. One of the people she lays a so-called gift on is Ella. As a baby Ella has no Idea what happened but as she grows older it becomes more of a problem. Now her mother has just died and she is sent to live with the most horrible people.
Some questions I had are how did Lucinda know when Ella was born, how does the prince know her mother, how did the little gnome wander to the ogres?
So far ella was cursed when she was born by a fairy who thought she was helping but actually made things worse. my question is how did they even know the fairy or did she just show up
so far i think ella enchanted is a pretty good book but i think that somethings are unfair like that if someone said ella buy me an apple she would be forced to do it but other than that i think its genre would definetly be magical but i dont know about a nonfiction book I think 5th or maybe even 6th grade would be good grades to read books like ella enchanted instead of reading about dragons and monsters for boys and instead of unicorns and rainbows for girls i would also really want to see the movie but im not sure yet but 1 thing i like about ella is she seems so nice and even if ella didnt have the curse on her she still would do some of the things she is commanded to do and 1 thing i really like about the book is its not a boyish book and its not a girly book but im sure i wouldnt want ellas curse what about you guys
i think it would be strange if we lived like ella does because she seems like is in a really boring old dusty place with bums like everyone else exept theyre houses,people, and citys looked different
I was wondering when did ellas mom die and how was there a hurricane or a tsunami or an earthquake was she threatened or did she lose when she was in labor?
Well I don't think that she would know when Ella was born unless someone told her about it, but she also could of known because Mandy the cook said that some of the creatures could tell the future so maybe thats how she knew.
If Ella is supposed to break the curse but every time she tries she feels sick. I can see why the dad sent the girl to finishing school. It would be hard to take care of her while your trading.
daer Kaelin I think it would be fun to live in a house like that and some people still live in that type of house and they don't have house like we do.
daer Kaelin you know when your mom or dad yells at you to get your choures done well they are jest yelling at you so you can be responsible and that is what Ella's mom is doing jest tring to make her responsible.
But she said that she would not undo the curse when the family asked her to. Also I want to know How the magic book deos what it does, besides its a magic, and I thought tha it was a person turned into a book.
24 comments:
So far Ella Enchanted is about a girl who is cursed by a fairy who thinks she's giving gifts when she’s really laying a curse of the person. One of the people she lays a so-called gift on is Ella. As a baby Ella has no Idea what happened but as she grows older it becomes more of a problem. Now her mother has just died and she is sent to live with the most horrible people.
Some questions I had are how did Lucinda know when Ella was born, how does the prince know her mother, how did the little gnome wander to the ogres?
So far ella was cursed when she was born by a fairy who thought she was helping but actually made things worse. my question is how did they even know the fairy or did she just show up
so far i think ella enchanted is a pretty good book but i think that somethings are unfair like that if someone said ella buy me an apple she would be forced to do it but other than that i think its genre would definetly be magical but i dont know about a nonfiction book I think 5th or maybe even 6th grade would be good grades to read books like ella enchanted instead of reading about dragons and monsters for boys and instead of unicorns and rainbows for girls i would also really want to see the movie but im not sure yet but 1 thing i like about ella is she seems so nice and even if ella didnt have the curse on her she still would do some of the things she is commanded to do and 1 thing i really like about the book is its not a boyish book and its not a girly book but im sure i wouldnt want ellas curse what about you guys
i think it would be strange if we lived like ella does because she seems like is in a really boring old dusty place with bums like everyone else exept theyre houses,people, and citys looked different
dear samantha dident you say that Lucinda was a fairy so she probley knows that tip of thing.
I think think when lucinda put that curse on ella it was a mistake because everyone does make mistakes even paris hilton
Dear kaelin she probley new Lucinda because she did not want her to give her her gift.
I was wondering when did ellas mom die and how was there a hurricane or a tsunami or an earthquake was she threatened or did she lose when she was in labor?
what is the fathers job?
Well I don't think that she would know when Ella was born unless someone told her about it, but she also could of known because Mandy the cook said that some of the creatures could tell the future so maybe thats how she knew.
If Ella is supposed to break the curse but every time she tries she feels sick. I can see why the dad sent the girl to finishing school. It would be hard to take care of her while your trading.
I think mum ogre is mean because of the way she is in the book.ellas dad was a trader for living
But she also but the curse on the married coupleso they could never leave each other" no horror,gift"p. 124
I thoght this book was going to be very boring but it was very exciting and I would reccommened this book to anyone.
daer Kaelin I think it would be fun to live in a house like that and some people still live in that type of house and they don't have house like we do.
Dear Kaelin I think she did put the curse on Ella on propous because any wich or fairy can undo it's spell.
Daer Kaelin Ella's mom died by a sikeness not by a earthqauke or any of the other stuf you said.
daer Kaelin you know when your mom or dad yells at you to get your choures done well they are jest yelling at you so you can be responsible and that is what Ella's mom is doing jest tring to make her responsible.
But she said that she would not undo the curse when the family asked her to. Also I want to know How the magic book deos what it does, besides its a magic, and I thought tha it was a person turned into a book.
the book was very surprising at the end but i dont want to end the surprise so i wont say. i think lucinda didnt want to take the curse off of her.
maybe it was in animal or maybe the mom is the book.because everyone lies
Lucinda would't undo the the curse when she asked her to in the room
I dont get why lucinda put it on both of them
She put it on both of them so that the would never want to leave each other
She put it on both of them so that the would never want to leave each other
Post a Comment